THE ART OFMONTY.
MENU ☰
THE MONTY FILES / ISSUE 028ARTICLE FILE 028 / 560

FIRST IMPRESSIONSWHAT SHE NOTICES

WHAT WOMEN LIKETHE ART OF MONTY ✳ EST. 2026
THE GENTLEMAN'S READING ROOMARTICLE FILE 028 / 560ALL THE MONTY FILES ↗

Women notice different things first about men: appearance, expression, manner, confidence or how a man treats the people around him. There's no reliable universal checklist of shoes, height or jawlines. You can control basic grooming, a welcoming manner and whether the person meeting you feels heard.

According to certain corners of the internet, a woman meets a man and immediately conducts a silent inspection. First she measures his jaw, then his bank balance, then his shoes, then the precise number of millimetres between his eyebrows. By the time he's said hello, she's apparently built a complete psychological profile and decided whether his descendants may inherit the family silver.

What an exhausting existence women must lead in these stories. And what a convenient way to sell a chap an expensive watch.

Women do notice things when they meet men, just as men notice things about women. Appearance matters to some degree, first impressions can be quick, and different people are drawn to different qualities. But women are not a single international judging panel, and there is no universally agreed list of seven masculine features that guarantees attraction.

If you want to make a better first impression, you can do considerably more than polish your shoes and hope to resemble the lead in a fragrance advertisement. You can think about how you make another person feel in your company.

01 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

The first impression begins before the first sentence

Illustrated scene featuring Monty for the article: What Do Women Notice First About a Man? Not Quite What the Internet Tells You
THE ART OF MONTYFILE 028 / AN ILLUSTRATED SCENE

Imagine walking into a gathering. One man stands stiffly in the doorway, scanning the room as though he's there to assess a security threat. Another chats pleasantly to the host, moves aside to let people pass and looks comfortable despite knowing only a few faces.

You know almost nothing about either man's life, yet you have an impression of them. It might be wrong, naturally. The stiff fellow could be a delightful person suffering a particularly grim day. First impressions are sketches, not verdicts.

Women may notice your posture, expression, grooming, movement, voice or manner. Which details attract her attention will depend on the woman, the circumstances and what she's looking for. A crowded pub isn't a quiet dinner; a job interview isn't a house party. People are constantly responding to context.

Instead of trying to manipulate every detail, aim for an accessible, relaxed presence. A friendly greeting and awareness of the people around you can tell someone more about your manners than a carefully engineered power pose.

02 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

Yes, appearance matters. No, that doesn't settle it

Let's dispatch the elephant in the perfectly tailored room. Physical attraction is real. People respond to faces, bodies, grooming, clothes and countless personal preferences. Anyone claiming that appearance never matters is being rather generous with the truth.

But attraction isn't a single universal score. A beard that makes one woman weak at the knees reminds another of an old geography teacher. One loves a beautifully turned-out man; another prefers somebody casual. Someone might notice your smile first, while someone else is drawn to your voice or the way you move.

Research on speed dating has explored how people's stated ideals compare with their interest in actual people they meet. The findings are a useful warning against treating questionnaire preferences as reliable predictions of chemistry. Real encounters have rather more going on than a shopping list.

So present yourself well without attempting to become an entirely different human specimen. Be clean, wear clothes that suit the occasion and fit you comfortably, and take basic care of your appearance. That makes your first impression easier; it doesn't entitle you to anybody's attraction.

03 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

A smile isn't a seduction trick

One of the most underrated qualities in a first encounter is looking as though you're pleased to be there.

A woman may notice whether you seem approachable, especially if she's deciding whether to talk to you. But remember that there's no guaranteed facial formula. Some people naturally look serious; others smile easily. Neither trait defines their entire character.

The better aim is to let your interest show honestly. If she's told a delightful story, enjoy it. If you're nervous, you can still offer a friendly hello. Don't become so obsessed with appearing confident that you forget the more useful objective of being pleasant company.

04 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

Your voice can do a lot of the introduction

You needn't cultivate a baritone that sounds like gravel being poured into a luxury car. Women have different preferences, and forcing an artificial voice is liable to make you sound like you're recovering from a very serious throat infection.

What helps conversation is being understandable. Speak clearly, at a comfortable volume and at a pace that lets the other person join in. If the place is noisy, adjust without barking in her ear. If you find yourself racing through a speech because you're nervous, slow down enough to hear her answer.

There is a difference between a confident voice and one that takes control of the room regardless of whether anybody wishes to hear it. You can be interesting without shouting over everyone. The most impressive man at a dinner party is rarely the one who monopolises the entire conversation with a story about his gym membership.

How you use your voice matters at least as much as trying to produce a particular pitch. Tone, warmth and interest are things your date can experience directly.

05 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

She may notice how you treat everyone else

Consider the man who is exquisite to his date and appalling to the waiter. He compliments her dress, holds her coat and asks about her family. Then the food arrives five minutes late and he speaks to the young server as though addressing a troublesome stablehand in 1840.

There are few faster ways to reveal that your charm comes with conditions.

Notice how you behave towards people who cannot offer you a romantic reward: staff, friends, an older relative at a gathering, the person struggling to navigate a crowded doorway. Courtesy needn't be theatrical. Say please, thank people, make space and handle mistakes without turning them into a moral crisis.

A woman may read those little choices as clues about your character. She may also have a perfectly sound objection to spending an evening with somebody who mistreats others. Neither reaction requires a psychology degree.

Don't perform kindness where she can see it and become dreadful the moment she leaves. That's not a dating strategy. It's a character problem with stage lighting.

06 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

Attention is rather more flattering than self-advertisement

There's a peculiar species of first-date man who treats the evening as a chance to launch his personal brand. Within ten minutes, she knows the make of his car, the price of his flat and that the managing director personally requested his attendance at a conference in Birmingham.

Meanwhile, he doesn't know what she does for work because he hasn't allowed the subject to arise.

Having achievements is fine. Being proud of them is fine. But an impressive résumé isn't the same thing as connection. People also notice whether you're curious about them, whether you respond to what they say and whether you can share the conversational space.

Research on close relationships identifies perceived responsiveness—feeling understood, validated and cared for—as important to intimacy. That doesn't mean attentive listening automatically makes a stranger romantically attracted to you. It does suggest that being heard matters when people form and maintain a connection.

So ask something you're genuinely curious about. Remember her answer. Share a little of yourself. You can let the conversation reveal your life without delivering an annual report.

07 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

Confidence looks less complicated up close

When some men hear that women like confidence, they imagine swagger, commanding gestures and the ability to walk into a room as though they've just purchased the building. I have met men who achieved all three and were still exceptionally tiresome.

A more appealing version of confidence is the ability to relax into who you are. You can offer an opinion without needing agreement. You can make a small mistake without collapsing. You can acknowledge nerves. You can say, “I don't know,” when you don't know.

This isn't a promise that every woman will be attracted to such a man. Some will prefer different temperaments. But comfort with yourself makes social interaction easier and avoids the exhausting performance of pretending to be someone taller, richer, louder or more mysterious.

You don't need to win every anecdote, dominate every discussion or compete with the man at the next table. You're allowed to be a man enjoying an evening. Quite revolutionary, really.

08 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

The little details that can sink an otherwise good impression

Bad breath. A shirt that looks as though it's spent the afternoon under a car seat. Talking while the other person is speaking. Checking your phone whenever a moment grows quiet. Turning up late without acknowledging it. Making jokes at someone else's expense and expecting applause.

These are not secret feminine preferences. They're ordinary matters of care and respect. Plenty of men would find them unattractive in a prospective partner too.

You can improve the basics without buying a new wardrobe or inventing a persona. Shower, attend to your teeth, choose clean clothes, arrive when you said you would and put the phone away when somebody's giving you their time.

Then don't ruin all that by becoming fanatical about perfection. A slightly creased cuff or an unexpectedly muddy pavement is not the end of romantic civilisation. Being able to handle such things with good humour may say something more useful about you than immaculate tailoring ever could.

09 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

Don't confuse a woman's preferences with a verdict on your worth

Suppose you meet a woman who doesn't find you attractive. Perhaps you're not her physical type. Perhaps your humour doesn't land. Perhaps she wants a very different life. It's tempting to turn that into a deficiency and start examining yourself for faults.

Resist the urge. Compatibility is not an examination with a universal marking scheme. Her reaction tells you something about the connection between two particular people. It doesn't describe your total value on the open market for human affection.

The reverse is also true. If she seems delighted by you, enjoy it without concluding you've mastered a scientific formula that can be applied to every woman thereafter.

Dating becomes considerably less grim when you stop treating women as a single audience and start treating each encounter as the meeting of two specific characters with their own tastes.

10 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

What should you concentrate on before meeting her?

You can prepare sensibly. Dress for the occasion. Check you've got the time and venue right. Attend to hygiene. Think about whether you're bringing decent energy to the meeting, especially if you've had a stressful day. Take enough interest in the world that you have things worth talking about.

Then turn your attention outward. You don't have to analyse your smile every twelve seconds or rehearse your opening sentence until it resembles a hostage statement. Once the conversation starts, there's another person there. The interesting task is getting to know her.

And remember, you're allowed to notice things too. Does she seem kind? Curious? Funny? Considerate? Does her company suit you? Attraction ought not to be a one-way audition in which you remain forever desperate for a pass mark.

11 / FROM THE MONTY FILES

The part nobody can manufacture

Ultimately, a first impression is the beginning of a story, not the story itself. You might look handsome in the doorway and turn out dull. You might arrive a little nervous and become thoroughly engaging once the conversation warms up. She may feel immediate attraction; she may take time to get to know you; she may never feel it.

No honest adviser can guarantee which outcome follows a neat haircut and a warm hello.

But you can give yourself a sensible chance: take care of your appearance, behave well towards people, bring something of your genuine personality and show curiosity about the woman in front of you.

If she likes what she finds, marvellous. If not, all you've lost is the fantasy that every woman is looking for the same man. And between ourselves, that fantasy was an absolute nuisance anyway.

END OF FILE 028RETURN TO THE MONTY FILES ↗
MORE FROM THE READING ROOM

THE NEXT
CHAPTER.

BROWSE EVERY OPEN FILE ↗
THE PERFECT PLACE TO START

SEVEN
SECRETS.
ONE MONTY.

Our free 14-page introduction to the world of attraction. A little knowledge, a lot of cheek.

GET THE FREE GUIDE ↗